![]() |
Source: Google Image |
Sunday, 10 June 2012
The Unknown World Of Polygamy
Well, I have been aware of the definition polygamy and its practice in some Muslim countries where the law allows men to have up to four wives in certain circumstances. However what really sparked my interest to further knowledge my self about this topic is the way North American polygamous individuals practice it, which is usually with 5 to 15 wives and over 100s of children. Polygamy is not greatly common and is very secretly practised that is why I also was interested learning about it. During my research I have learned that North Americans do not have up to date information on polygamous communities instead they have very strong arguments against polygamy. I also noticed during my research that all articles either argue against polygamy or try and support polygamy but no article mentions pros and cons side by side. After all, this learning experience was unique and full of new information.
Polygamy In My Views Based On The Bountiful Community
Source: Youtube, 16x9: Inside Bountiful: Polygamy investigation
Certainly we are all aware of the fact that news is bias. In my opinion the majority if not all of news are influenced by the attitudes of writers, directors, interviewers, editors and photographers. Watching this video makes me wonder how much the definition of polygamy is created by media.
In my previous blogs I have been neutral not supporting either side, trying to interpret all the different views and perspectives of weather polygamy should or should not be legal. However, with reference to this video I will now be listing my points of view to why polygamy should remain to be illegal.
Partially I think this video is intended to show polygamous people who undergo modern changes along with the rest of the world and showcase polygamy as not violating human rights. However me as a viewer was not convinced because:
-Winston Blackmore polygamous family are still implying strict gender roles.
-It is necessaries for a child to have equal love and attention from both parents, however Blackmore has more then 130 children which is impossible to even remember their names.
-Portrays how much polygamy is influenced by the United States.
-It capters how ones interpretation of polygamy is forced upon others.
-Blackmores wife mentions how she has to preaper breakfast for around 200 people which in my opinion is an example how polygamy limits individual growth.
-In six second footage (between 3:35 and 3:41) it makes me question family values polygamous individuals claim to have because of Blackmores interaction with his daughters like they are strangers.
-Blackmore is very uncertain and hesitant when answering questions from the reporter which makes me think Blackmore is not telling the truth.
Overall the Blackmore family does not showcase stability and a strong definition of polygamy that can support the legalization of polygamy; each person reports different opinions of what polygamous lifestyle is. I was not able to spot one common complementarity definition of polygamy in Blackmores community which influences my final statement; Polygamy should not be legalized.
-Portrays how much polygamy is influenced by the United States.
-It capters how ones interpretation of polygamy is forced upon others.
-Blackmores wife mentions how she has to preaper breakfast for around 200 people which in my opinion is an example how polygamy limits individual growth.
-In six second footage (between 3:35 and 3:41) it makes me question family values polygamous individuals claim to have because of Blackmores interaction with his daughters like they are strangers.
-Blackmore is very uncertain and hesitant when answering questions from the reporter which makes me think Blackmore is not telling the truth.
Overall the Blackmore family does not showcase stability and a strong definition of polygamy that can support the legalization of polygamy; each person reports different opinions of what polygamous lifestyle is. I was not able to spot one common complementarity definition of polygamy in Blackmores community which influences my final statement; Polygamy should not be legalized.
Friday, 8 June 2012
Does Polygamy Have Solutions
Polygamy is illegal in North America, however there are small communities who practice it which is illegal. Due to polygamist living a very secret life governments have not been up holding their laws. We as a country need to be aware of all the communities that surround us especially the ones who are breaking the law North Americans have a strong belief against. In my opinion the possible solution would be exposing this communities and making sure the government up holds its laws. One way of taking action is singing pledges against polygamy. In the other hand I believe that everyone should live the lifestyle they chose as long as it dose not damage them self and the people around. Having said that polygamous people live a lifestyle that our society is not familiar with, therefore I think we need to further educate ourselves to inssuer equality of those who practice non harmful polygamous relationship. Due to polygamy being know as a practice that violets women rights and those of children which was a major problem in the past for women and children to find help. However that is not the case in modern day society, there many groups and organizations that the victims can reach out to like: social workers, law enforcement, schooling systems, and websites that are against polygamy. The challenge that we need to find a solution to is if polygamy is illegal or not because clearly polygamous families are not giving up their belief and we as a society need to acknowledge it. We need to make polygamy legal so its a safe and open environment. However accompanied by laws against harmful polygamous relationships.
Source Citation: Google Image |
Thursday, 7 June 2012
Source: Google Image/ The hit television show that follows the lives of a polygamist family that try and showcase their polygamous family like every other one.
|
Those Who Support Polygamy And Those Who Do Not
As addressed before polygamy is claimed to be a religious right however its a right that is never been granted, not even in the early years where polygamy was more commonly practiced. I believe that the government has always had an enormous impact on this issues since it makes the biggest decisions and that is if polygamy can or can not be practised. Many polygamous family's and individuals who support them claim that the government is discriminating against their religious rights. However the Charter does not prohibit all discrimination, it only prohibits those forms of discrimination that can not be justified as reasonable. These argument is a set back for polygamous individuals that use this point in court, since they are being judged because they broke the law and are not there to argue against changing the law. In the other hand, polygamy certainly has not be justified as reasonable because of different reasons that occurred in the past like: sexual abuse, physical abuse, mental abuse, insest, lack of education, enforcement of this belief, and violating basic rights for both women and children. In all regards if these are results of polygamy then it should stay illegal however governments and communities should not be narrow minded and base there arguments in experiences that have happened decades ago. In my view many religions have individuals who practice there beliefs to different extents and ways that violate basic human rights. I would conclude the same about polygamy there are individuals which there interpretation on how they practice polygamy is harmful however there are many other family's that claim and show the practice of polygamy is not harmful and forced. Therefore we should look to find different solutions that do not completely banned polygamy.Polygamy is legal in certain Muslim and African countries so individuals coming from these countries living in North America are faced with the challenge of partially practician their religion. This situation is very challenging for North America because they practice polygamy secretly. Many women in this countries do not support polygamy however I believe that there strong religious beliefs prevents them from standing up against polygamy. As result it is hard to help them if they do not admit to it. Based on statistics the majority of North Americans do not believe in polygamy and therefore it creates this limited spectrum of those who believe in polygamy and those who do not which makes polygamy a controversial issue."Moroccan Men and Women Protest Plans to
Reduce Religious Strictures on Women, 2000."Gale World History in Context. Detroit: Gale,
2010. Gale World History In Context. Web. 8 June 2012.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)